'Silent Things' (Rob Brown, 2011) is a dramatised romantic comedy that
deals with asperger syndrome in young adults/teenagers. The narrative follows
the misunderstanding that comes with autism, and the stigma that comes with it.
After watching the film, I looked up the symptoms of Asperger's Syndrome
in children to find a lot of the symptoms
are displayed. I've listed 5 symptoms of
the disability and how it's been shown in the short.
COMMUNICATION DIFFICULTIES
The male lead suffers from Asperger's and shows no physical clues to suggest it. He
does disclose his disability during a shot-reverse-shot conversation with the
female lead. However, as the conversation progresses, you see the clear
stereotypes; more through personality and interaction with other characters.
Although the male is occupied, he doesn't make
eye contact with the female for the entirety of their initial conversation.
This is an accurate representation. Communication difficulties are frequent;
sufferers tend to lack eye contact, or have trouble using facial
expressions/gestures. This character progresses through the short and begins to
find a friend in the teenage girl. In figure 4. he begins to make eye contact -
this eye-line match is shown using an OTS shot. The depth of field focuses on
the male to highlight this conversation's importance.
SKILLED OR TALENT
Once the friendship's been
established, the two begin talking about the upcoming trip on the ferry. He
tells the female lead all the credentials to make a ferry move - obviously not
common knowledge to the majority, but something he just happens to know. One symptom
of asperger's is excelling in specific areas of knowledge or being
multi-talented in very hands on activities.
PROBLEMS WITH SOCIAL SKILLS
When
the two main characters begin talking, the male doesn't want to lead the
conversation in any way. Asperger's sufferers generally have difficulty
interacting in social situations. The female lead is left to ask the questions
as she constantly pushes some form of interaction. The main line that triggers
a form of interest is when the female lead shouts out to abusive on-lookers
that he is her boyfriend - the male accepts this form of flattery and uses it
as a form of comfort.
When
the male is waiting to board the ferry, he begins to have an internal breakdown
- he is centred on himself and becomes fixated on cutting everything around him
out. This is shown sound filters to position ourselves in an asperger's
sufferers mind. To other characters, this sound would be non-diegetic. However,
this problem with social skills results in questions being raised on whether he
is inappropriately taking the female on the ferry. Having a younger mind and
socialising with younger people can be another struggle that older people with
asperger's suffer with.
Working
again with the flattery that comes with comfort, many sufferers like to use
their imagination to help themselves. This can be from two extremes; the male
lead calls the female lead his friend when confronted by another character with
asperger's. The other character with asperger's asks how they can be friends
"if they only met today" - both of them display social awkwardness
when confronted with this unknown person. In conjunction with lack of
communication, the female lead shows physical clues that she suffers as well -
she's very tense in her body language, and touches her hands and face whenever
she's on screen.
The two asperger's sufferers find comfort in each other, and
the narrative shows the two rejoin as friends at the end of the short.
WHAT CAN I TAKE FROM THIS?
- I'm not very experienced in films that deal with (dis)ability, so to have this as the longest film to analyse really was helpful. Not necessarily a key skill/technique as well, but it had also opened by mind to asperger's, and made me interested enough to research more into this form of autism. The film was clearly successful in it's purpose if it made me want to look into it.
You have discussed the impact on you and what you have taken away with you from the film - good - do this for all the films.
ReplyDeleteUse more terminology throughout Alex.
Level 3